a landscape lover's blog

garden tales from a Brit abroad

Wall-to-wall green

Landscapelover is delighted to welcome fellow blogger Lula Alvarez (aka Camer@Work) from On Botanical Photography as a guest contributor for this post. We have both been visiting and photographing the green walls—or vertical gardens—of master botanist Patrick Blanc.

Vertical gardens are everywhere these days. Seen as a dramatic statement of green credentials, they are trumpeted as increasing biodiversity, improving air quality, reducing energy consumption (as they provide building insulation), absorbing urban noise, and helping manage storm water runoff. Some analysis is going on (for example, here and here) which seems to confirm many of these claims. Paris is one of several cities that has included vertical gardens in its plans for combatting climate change.

Green walls in the 13 arr

Ideas for improving thermal insulation for Paris tower blocks. Image from http://www.paris.fr

Green walls are created in a number of ways. Most obviously, climbing plants are placed at the foot of a wall and encouraged to grow up. Alternatively, plants start at the top and cascade down. Lawrence Halprin, for instance, used this top-down approach to smother concrete walls at Freeway Park in Seattle.

Lawrence Halprin green wall

Green walls at Freeway Park, 2004

We are lucky in Paris to have Patrick Blanc, one of the leading experts on planted walls, or murs végétals. As a botanist, Blanc realised that plants in the wild frequently do not need soil to grow, but can thrive on cliff faces, rocks and the trunks of other plants. So he devised a novel way of growing plants on walls. No soil at all is involved: his designs consist of a layer of felt stapled to a waterproof PVC sheet, which in turn is attached to a metal frame fitted against the wall. That’s it. The plants are established as seeds or cuttings on the felt, and are automatically watered (and fed) from above. He now installs such vertical gardens all over the world, but the French capital has the greatest number of his creations.

Lula and I have been visiting a number of Blanc’s gardens. Perhaps the best known is the 2005 green wall at the musée du Quai Branly in Paris. It is much photographed, with shots often also including a glimpse of the nearby Eiffel Tower.

Similar in style is a building on rue Belliard in Brussels. Installed in 2009 for Stam-Europe (a property investment firm), Blanc’s creation covers a windowed façade on a busy street. But Lula says that, in contrast to the lushness of the Paris example, it has been poorly maintained and some of the plants have died. The building is currently unoccupied, and advertised for sale or rent.

Lula's image of Rue BelliardLula's image of rue Belliard

Similar problems have occurred on the Parliament building in Brussels, where Lula reports that she was not allowed to take photos of Blanc’s 2006 installation because the wall is currently in such a bad condition. Restoration work is apparently underway, but it will not be fit to be photographed again until the summer.

Patrick Blanc walls also appear as small squares on the front of department stores, aiming to catch the eye of the passer-by and to suggest the shop’s eco-friendliness. One example is at BHV Homme, installed in 2007, tucked down a side street in Paris’s 4th arrondissement. It contains some surprising plants, including a few tough little mahonia aquifolium. BHV HommeLula found a similar 2008 Blanc garden on the front of Berlin’s Galeries Lafayette, which is housed in a stunning building designed by Jean Nouvel. The first photograph below is from last summer, and shows that some of the plants had died. But by November 2010, in the second photograph, the wall had been partially replanted and was again thriving. Lula's Galeries Lafayette, Berlin, June 2010Lula's GL Berlin, Nov 2010 Blanc started his career creating vertical gardens inside buildings, only later moving on to external sites, and he still installs interior green walls for some clients. The smallest example I have seen is a free-standing display, created in 2006 inside the Weleda store on Paris’s Avenue Franklin Roosevelt, designed no doubt to promote the store’s green credentials.

Such internal walls are less accessible to the casual passer-by — and also to the writers of this post. Lula managed to snap a photo from the street of the vertical garden inside Club Med premises on Avenue Louise in Brussels, after being told prior permission was needed to photograph inside. Her photograph shows that the long, low wall Blanc created in 2007 still looks lush and healthy.

Lula's Club Med

The Pershing Hall boutique hotel, just off the Champs Elysées, has another internal Blanc wall, installed in 2001. Luckily I was allowed to photograph it last month. It theatrically forms one whole side of the small dining room, and then extends up beyond the glass ceiling into an atrium, around which are arranged the hotel’s bedrooms.

 

Sadly, a series of dramatic green columns, installed by Blanc in 2005 in the stairwells of an underground car park at place des Ternes in the 17th arrondissement of Paris, have recently been abandoned. The water and artificial lights were turned off, and the plants have withered and died in the dry, dark conditions. They remain in place, now husk-like, a silent recrimination.

 

The most striking example I have seen of Blanc’s work was at the Caixa Forum post-modern art museum in Madrid. This converted warehouse, with its rusty steel façade, provides a stunning contrast with Blanc’s 2007 creation, installed on the wall of a neighbouring building.

Like all Blanc’s designs, the fifteen thousand plants for Caixa Forum were carefully chosen to suit the local climate, and have been arranged in painterly patterns to echo the contents of the museum.

Both Lula and I visited in February, as the plants were just coming into growth; later in the season, the wall is gorgeously lush, almost shaggy.

 

 

 

An even bigger example of Blanc’s work runs along one side of the Passage Delanos, a shortcut between two Paris train stations, Gare de l’Est and Gare du Nord. The 1,400m² vertical garden was installed in 2008 as part of the SNCF refurbishment of the area, and it transformed a dark alleyway into an exuberant green space in the city.

In late summer, there are sedums and other plants in flower on the wall, but even in early spring it has ferns, heucheras, grasses and helxine (baby’s tears), in broad swathes of yellow, light and dark green, brown and pinkish purple.

 

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

It is hard not to love these lush green creations. But is there a downside? Well, clearly—even from these few examples—like any garden, green walls will deteriorate if not properly maintained.

There are also concerns that vertical gardens may become a way of justifying denser development: some planning departments are already offering more building space to firms prepared to use green practices. It’s known as a “density incentive.” Let’s just hope that these delightful planted walls continue to be additional green space, and don’t become instead a vertical alternative to traditional parks.

About these ads

15 comments on “Wall-to-wall green

  1. Fantastic post! I didn’t know that green walls of this scale existed! I’m thrilled when I see even a planted flowerbox on the side of a building, but this is a whole other level!

  2. maggie
    March 4, 2011

    The photos are just great. I’ve seen a couple of the installations you show, but not the eerie place des Ternes. Disappointingly dead installation, but compellling photos.
    Thanks to both of you!

  3. Karin/Southern Meadows
    March 5, 2011

    Fabulous post! These walls are incredible and really a great use of space which brings some much needed greenery to all the concrete of the cities. It was unfortunate to read about the walls in Brussels that are not being maintained as needed. At the Atlanta Botanical Garden they created a herb wall with this same concept. It is really ingenious and a concept easily translated to a smaller, home scale!

  4. Carolflowerhillfarm
    March 5, 2011

    It is so exciting to see these green walls being planted all over the world. Very beautiful and I hope there is no downside to them. Maintenance must be an issue. I trust there are no poisons involved. This type of greening of buildings with a conscious effort to clean air and add beauty to the cityscape is quite extraordinary! Terrific post!!

  5. Jill, So fascinating. I loved seeing all these green walls. I can understand the concerns you expressed, but really there is no downside because development is a reality–better that it include plants. So exciting that you and Lula got together. Looking forward to our joint foray. Will it result in a post? Carolyn

  6. Garden Walk Garden Talk
    March 5, 2011

    I love seeing the living walls being both building architect and garden designer. When in architecture school, we learned of this in landscape architecture classes, but have never done it in practice. Sad to see them abandoned though.

  7. Malinda
    March 5, 2011

    Wow – What a fun post! I am so excited to see the Freeway Park in Seattle. – where I’m from. I used to walk over this everyday – it’s quite beautiful. A garden tucked in massive amounts of concrete – and more extensive than one would think. Planting on roofs and walls seems to help mitigate the baron feeling that the concrete world leaves. Somehow mitigating the damage of progress.

  8. Jean
    March 5, 2011

    What a treat to find two of my favorite bloggers together in one place. I found both the photographs and your analysis of the vertical gardens fascinating. It sounds as though some who commission vertical gardens from designers like Blanc, just like some who commission horizontal gardens from garden designers, don’t understand that gardens need gardeners to tend them and keep them healthy.

  9. landscapelover
    March 5, 2011

    Thanks for all the positive responses. Lula and I intend to keep looking for examples of green walls, and I will post again as we find them.
    We are delighted that people liked this post, and are already thinking about other possible collaborations.

  10. Fran Sorin
    March 8, 2011

    You already know that I’m a big fan of your photographs (GGW’s Picture This Contest) but now you’re writing about one of my favorite subjects….vertical gardening….with the renowned Patrick Blanc featured.

    It is an expansive, inspirational and beautifully written post! Thanks so much…Fran

  11. Thomas
    April 4, 2011

    Great post. We just had a company visit our office here who is installing vertical gardens here in the States. Interestingly, their biggest clients are corporations who use green walls as a form of advertising. It was a way of attracting attention to their company, but also branding them as a “green” company. The commercialization of gardens always throws up flags for me, but I’m so eager for vertical gardens to spread everywhere, perhaps it’s not a bad thing. Every great garden needs a patron . . .

    Thanks for this!

  12. landscapelover
    April 4, 2011

    Thanks for the comment. There clearly are organisations (including some of those mentioned in this post) who install green walls mainly to trumpet their supposed green credentials. And some commentators are dubious that Blanc’s walls bring any real environmental benefits – see for example http://www.gardenvisit.com/blog/2010/07/11/patrick-blanc-green-walls-are-beautiful-but-are-they-sustainable/ and http://mars.stephenalton.com/posts/sustainable/sustainability-misguided-architects-and-greenwalls and http://www.gardeninggonewild.com/?p=16321
    But I still think they probably contribute more to our well-being than a mass of bare concrete…

  13. Pingback: Nature under totalitarian rule « Landscape Lover's Blog

  14. Pingback: Prosperous&Poor - Paris’ Vertical Gardens

  15. Pingback: » Longwood garden’s vertical garden

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Discover other landscape lover articles on these sites:

ThinkinGardens
On Botanical Photography
GGW
Soiled and Seeded
Along Life's Highway

Enter your email address to subscribe to my blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 224 other followers

Categories

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 224 other followers